October 3rd, 2025 10:36 AM by Joe Minotto
Good Fences make Great Neighbors...
A quarter of homeowners (25%) have shelled out at least $1,000 dealing with bad neighbors, so good neighbors are a top priority for buyers.
ST. LOUIS — Having good neighbors matters as much as price or location when buying a home for 82% of Americans, according to a new report from Anytime Estimate, an online publication owned by Clever Real Estate.
In fact, about 1 in 5 Americans (19%) say they'd pay $10,000 or more above the price of a comparable home to avoid bad neighbors, while 1 in 8 (12%) would pay $20,000 extra.
Similarly, 19% would spend at least $10,000 more if it guaranteed they would never have to interact with their neighbors, and 13% would pay at least $20,000.
Over half of Americans (56%) have complaints about their neighbors, and 49% of homeowners have had to spend money on neighbor issues such as landscaping, building fences, legal fees, and repairing damage.
About 49% of Americans say a neighbor has wronged them in the past. In addition, 29% have felt judged by their neighbors, and 22% have neighbors who have made them feel unsafe or uncomfortable.
More than 1 in 8 homeowners (13%) even believe their neighbors or their neighbors' homes would cause problems selling their own home. Additionally, fewer than half of Americans (44%) say their neighbors made an effort to meet them when they moved in.
Just 35% say they never have neighbor issues; yet, despite this, 90% of Americans believe they are a good neighbor themselves.
Almost half of respondents (45%) would be open to moving if they didn't like their neighbors, and 26% have actually considered it.
88% of Americans see neighbors who frequently yell or fight as a dealbreaker, while 84% feel the same about neighbors who let their dog bark excessively.
About 57% say it would be a dealbreaker when buying a home to see a neighbor display a Confederate flag.
Conversely, Americans say a good neighbor is trustworthy (65%), quiet (51%), and maintains their home and yard (47%).
Overall, 86% of Americans think it's important to get along with their neighbors. Millennials (53%) and Gen Z (52%), however, are more likely to say it's normal or common to dislike neighbors compared to boomers (34%).
Source: Anytime Estimate
© 2025 Florida Realtors®
Want to know if a home is still on the market, or if the price has changed? We can help. Simply fill out the information below and with no obligation to you we'll get back to you with your requested information. We guarantee your privacy.